Would You Marry Mr. Collins?

Vera Nazarian

First, before we discuss the happy prospect of matrimony with Mr. Collins—Happy St. Patrick’s Day, everyone!

And second, it’s contemporary month, and I must confess upfront that I also have a contemporary Austen-related novel in the works. I’d almost forgotten about it since other projects got in the way over the past several very busy months, but I am so glad we’re doing this month, because now it gives me a chance to share with you a little bit about this very funny and yes, romantic book.

It is tentatively titled Armenian, Looking For Mr. Darcy, and is a cross between My Big Fat Greek Wedding (except substitute Armenian as the ethnicity), with echoes of the Jane Austen Book Club.

The premise: an Armenian-Russian single young woman working a drudge office job prank-calls people randomly out of the phone book…  with the last name of Darcy.

How did this craziness start? And where does it take the heroine?

Here’s an excerpt from Armenian, Looking For Mr. Darcy:

I was at my desk, and my cubicle neighbor Rosalie was doing something noisy with breakfast tupperware—sometimes I swear Rosalie makes fajitas at her desk. She’s got a larder in one desk drawer and a pantry in the other, next to the stationery supplies. Anyway, Rosalie took an incoming personal call and I heard her start complaining about the pay and the economy, of all things. I felt like saying, “Shut up, already, before Angela our supervisor hears you.” Not that taking personal calls is a big deal in this office, but Rosalie has such a goddamn loud voice she could out-scream Celine Dion, and you really do not want to rag on your current job if you can help it, not when it can all go away at the drop of a hat—Obama, save us, and the Angel of Layoffs pass over this floor and take Accounting instead.

Well, to create a distraction—I could see Angela’s silhouette moving around like a shadow puppet through the translucent lowered blinds of her glass office—I decided to take a pretend customer call and make it loud.

I picked up the desk handset with the sleazy finesse of a long time support technician, and started talking into the dial tone.

“Yes, this is Armineh Nersessian. Yes, documentation. Aha. Okay, Aha. Yes, let me check that for you, okay? Just a moment please.”

Then I pretended I needed a fact check, and leaned over the cubicle divider and said loudly, “Rosalie? Sorry, can you check something for me, for a sec? I have a client needing urgent data check on the Whaley Horton book.”

Rosalie looked at me, and I began making urgent eye-roll and facial tick motions to indicate Angela’s office. She got it, and her voice went down at least twenty decibels and she whispered into the phone “Call you back later, okay…”

And then we continued enacting the drama, since Angela’s office door opened.

“Who is it?” said Rosalie, making her own version of facial ticks that involved crossing her eyes and jaw-popping weirdness around the mouth area.

“It’s a… uhm… a Mr. Darcy,” I said. The name just popped into my head.

Rosalie almost snarfed. At that point we heard Don three cubes over perk up and say, “Mr. Darcy? What? No way, a Mr. Darcy? As in, Jane Austen?” And his dark head popped up over the cubicle wall.

I tried to ignore Don, who is either metrosexual or gay but no one knows for sure, but this makes Don very conversant in pop culture topics and also very blabby in general. Give him any excuse to stop working and start talking and he eats it up.

“The client,” I continued, facing Rosalie, “wants to know if the production date is nineteen fifty or nineteen sixty three. Can you please look it up right now?”

“Ok, sure, give me a second.”

Angela was out of her office, sleek and catlike in dark senior editorial powersuit—no, kidding actually: she’s neurotic and slouchy, in a slightly ill-fitting-around-the-chest beige blouse and khaki casual pants—heels clicking on the floor, then going dull on the carpet portion of the cube farm. Oh sh*t. She is going to want to know who, what, etc.

And then it hit me. I grabbed the phonebook from the reference stack on the left of my desk shelves, and flipped directly to “D.”

Darby…  Darchen… Darcy! Yes, about two pages of Darcys. I picked one at random, a Joseph W. Darcy, and quickly scrawled his phone number on my notepad to make it look real. Then I shut the phonebook and put it away.

Now, if only the Universe takes mercy on me and there’s voicemail. Please, God, voicemail, voicemail.

Curious what happens next? MUAHAHA! You’ll just have to read the novel. I hope to be done with it in a few months.

And now, to make a segue from Mr. Darcy, the most attractive mate possible, to Mr. Collins, his pretty much complete opposite, I want to ask everyone this very blunt series of questions:

1) If you were Elizabeth Bennett—knowing what you do only as far as that point in the book, and also being aware of the difficult social circumstances and your limited chances for future security and happiness—would you refuse Mr. Collins or accept his proposal?

2) If you were Charlotte Lucas, would you accept Mr. Collins’s proposal?

3) If you were yourself, and were bodily transported by magic into the book Pride and Prejudice, like the heroine of Lost in Austen, and were faced with nothing better than a marriage proposal from Mr. Collins, would you accept or refuse him?

As for me—I am not so sure I would refuse him, and very likely might accept his proposal! I suppose practicality and need for security would trump all concerns about the dork-awful personality and general yuckiness of this man. Seriously, he may be unattractive, but at least he is not a scoundrel like Mr. Wickham! So yeah, Charlotte and I could do worse!

Let’s hear your thoughts!

 

Vera Nazarian

VERA NAZARIAN is a two-time Nebula Award Nominee, award-winning artist, and member of Science Fiction and Fantasy Writers of America, a writer and reader with a penchant for moral fables and stories of intense wonder, true love, and intricacy.

28 Responses to Would You Marry Mr. Collins?

  • My question about Mr. Collins is slightly different. When Elizabeth refuses him, she believes that Jane will soon marry Mr. Bingley. If Mr. Collins had shown up two months later instead, when it was clear that there was no Bingley marriage on the horizon, would Elizabeth have made the same choice, knowing that marrying him would make the difference between her mother and sisters facing poverty or having a home after her father’s death? I’m not sure I’d like her very much if she refused him at that point. It’s one thing to choose poverty for herself over marriage to Mr. Collins, and another if it starts involving other people.

    • That’s an excellent point, Abigail.

      And there are several other instances like that throughout the book where such a decision may make more or less common sense.

      When Elizabeth finds out that Lydia eloped with Wickham and all of their reputations are suddenly in danger of being tarnished by association, making the whole Bennet brood unmarriageable, might be another critical point.

    • Jakki L. says:

      Sounds like you have another variation on your hands, Abigail! :wink:

  • I don’t think Elizabeth would ever have married Mr. Collins. She has learned from her father, and believes what he later tells her, “Do any thing but marry without affection.” She does not look on marriage in a purely prudential light. It is like what Lady Russell says about Anne, that at nineteen she might look higher, though at twenty-three she’d like to see her settled with a Charles Musgrove. Lizzy is only twenty, knows her own perfections, and is foolishly romantic enough to consider the possibility of marrying Wickham. She isn’t even thinking of her family, and that’s why Mrs. Gardiner has to gently remind her to be prudent. As for me, I don’t think I’d mind Mr. Collins so much (absent a Mr. Darcy). He’s good natured and, as Charlotte shows us, fairly easily managed. Although his affection for her at the start was certainly “imaginary,” after they have been married for awhile it is clear that he is both fond and proud of his dear Charlotte. Love your story, and love your questions, dear Vera!

    • Thanks, Diana, and your answers are perfect! :)

      You make some amazing points about Elizabeth being indoctrinated by her father’s idealistic notions, and yes!

  • BeckyC says:

    I agree with Diana. I don’t think Elizabeth could ever marry Collins! (But that would be an interesting ‘what if”. Elizabeth feels pressured by circumstances to marry Collins and Darcy comes to save the day!) Her family would have to drop significantly lower to get her to even stop to think twice.

    But what about Collins? He thinks pretty highly of himself. There is no way he would ever offer to Elizabeth when her life changes. He was pretty proud of dodging that bullet.

    • And that’s great point too, Becky, about Mr. Collins not offering for her twice! I was thinking more along the lines of, what if his original offer had come at a different, more tough time in her life…

  • Laura Hile says:

    In real life? Oh dear. The stakes were awfully high, and Charlotte’s chances for finding love—especially in such a limited social circle—were slim. If I were her, would I marry Mr Collins? Probably.

    But then, I’ve always got a weather eye peeled for safety in a storm. If I were Anne Elliot, for example, I would have married Charles Musgrove! (He is a good-hearted fellow, and so much easier to live with than Sir Walter and Elizabeth!)

    But Austen presents us with another young woman, Maria Bertram, whose social circle and prospects were not so limited. Why did she marry James Rushworth? Did she think his fortune and fine estate would make up for Henry Crawford’s disinterest? Was it spite? Greed? Or just plain foolishness? If I were Miss Bertram, would I marry Mr Rushworth? Definitely not.

    • I think Maria married Mr. Rushworth purely out of spite, plus she really wanted to show off the fortune and “shove it” in Henry Crawford’s face. I also don’t think Maria was mature enough to understand what marriage meant, plus her easy life up to that point did not make her value fortune for its own sake and for security so much as a social “weapon.”

      Excellent points, Laura!

  • Lynne says:

    Depending on which Mr Collins the one in 1995 series or the one in the 2005 film The sycophant Collins in the series I would not even consider marrying and do not blame Elizabeth for not doing so. But the one in the film was not a grovelling idiot which the series had played him to be.

    As to my marrying him I still do not think that I would do so either. As Abigail states Jane had seemed to have captured the heart of Mr Bingley and so Elizabeth thought she could marry for love. Also, like has been stated Mr Bennet encouraged her to follow her heart.

    For me Elizabeth did the correct thing, Mr Bennet looked hail and hearty, so would have plenty of years of life in front of him.

    • Lynne, again, good points, and we can all agree (knowing the plot and the happy ending) that Elizabeth did the right thing. :) But the “what ifs” remain, considering the position of women of her time, and their dire dependence on a good marriage to be settled in life, and to provide for their family in the only way they could.

  • Susan Kaye says:

    I”m not big on the who-would-or-wouldn’t-marry-who(m). The backside of a marriage always looks different than you think it will.

    I do LOVE your premise for the contemporary, Vera. I like will-o-the-wisp kinds of plots that take us into the unknown. This one has lots of scope for crazy, serious, and romantic subplots.

  • And don’t forget that if I married Mr. Collins I’d get British citizenship…

  • Sophia Rose says:

    Enjoyed your excerpt! Ha! Sounds like a riot of fun.

    As to Collins- that is a tough answer because there are so many variables. I’m going to cop out and say ‘maybe’.

    If I had Elizabeth’s personality (which I do to some extent) and the environment of her home due to her parents mistake in marriage (not to mention that her dad’s still very much alive and Jane is very much still beautiful ), I’d say ‘heck no! I’d commit murder on his person within a fortnight.’

    I know the average person of those times would have curtseyed prettily and said ‘I thank you sir’ just to keep back the scary possibility of being left without resources when her father died. My answer would not change, but I might have paused to consider the repercussions- cranky old lady’s companion here I come.

    Good discussion question! Thanks!

  • Jakki L. says:

    Now I am dying to know what happens next in your contemporary piece, Vera! Looking forward to reading the rest! :grin:
    As for marrying that odious man, man that is a difficult one. I suppose I could stomach it if it would help my family, then I think about the marriage bed and cringe. :oops: Not sure I could do that. I would like to think I was more like Elizabeth in that I could turn down his proposal, but I think my sense of duty to my family might outweigh that and again, I cringe. :oops:

  • Stephanie L says:

    Hmmm…I don’t know. My personality would be to tell him to go chew on his socks and then be a governess or something so as not to have to put up with him… :oops: however, I have to agree with Abigail in that at the point in the book where the proposal takes place, Elizabeth has every reason to believe that Jane will be Mrs. Bingley and that everything will be fabulous, so in her shoes, I think she did the right thing. Later on (in a what if), if he had proposed after Mr. Bingley left for London and she hated Mr. Darcy and Aunt Gardiner had warned her to be prudent about Mr. Wickham…maybe a different thing. I’ve always wondered what would have happened if Lizzie had run off with Wickham instead of Lydia. Would Mr. Darcy have swept her away (to Gretna Greene et al) and saved the day or thanked her foolishness for saving his heart?

    • That’s an excellent question, what might have happened had Wickham and Elizabeth run off instead of Wickham and Lydia…

      I bet Mr. Darcy would have intervened big time! :)

  • Lúthien84 says:

    Thanks for the lovely excerpt from your writing-in-progress. Can’t wait to learn what happens next. I’ll look forward to the day when it is completed.

    As for your questions, here are my thoughts:

    1) I would not marry Mr Collins knowing I could not respect and would laugh at him for his appalling manners and dimwit for even a day. How could I stand him for the rest of my life? I would really grow frustrated and loose my mind.

    2) Since Charlotte thinks only of practicality and the fact that someone will look after her in order not to burden her family, then I think I would accept.

    3) With my modern sensibilities, I would definitely not marry Mr Collins. I would not want someone to stifle my freedom of expression and independence unless I found someone that I love and he loves me.

    Just my two cents!

    • Love your answers! Especially the idea that the modern you might not want to have your freedom stifled by the likes of Mr. Collins! :)

      It really is hard to reconcile for us how women thought and felt (and resigned themselves) in those days.

  • Thank you for the question, Vera. It got me thinking.

    I agree that Lizzy isn’t considering her family’s situation at all, which is why she is horrified that Charlotte accepted Collins — even though Charlotte is older and presumably on the shelf. Practical considerations don’t matter to Lizzy, which is exactly why she turns down Darcy as well. She is definitely looking for a soul mate.

    Would I have married Mr. Collins? I wouldn’t have, because he would have driven me crazy, but I might have married someone else for practical considerations, someone a bit more sensible. I would have turned down Darcy the first time, certainly!

  • Vera, I’m with Abigail on this one – she made some very valid points.

    As for myself, I’m afraid that if I was in the same situation, but that my sister was NOT expected to soon be married to a man who loved her and had 5,000 a year, that I would, indeed, feel moved to accept Mr. Collins’ proposal. (Hopefully, though, I’d be able to mold him a little bit here and there. Those table manners…!) ;)

Our Novels

P&P: RC

P&PRC_badgered2Info on P&P:RC page

Be sure to vote!

*Giveaways

Enter our monthly contest using the Rafflecopter form on the
Giveaway Page
.
All rules and prizes are listed there! Click the image or link provided.

Our Imprint

Subscribe

Enter your email address to receive updates of our blog posts.

Delivered by FeedBurner

Contact Us

Authors can be contacted via their email link on the Austen Authors page. For general information or to contact the admins, click the image to the left.

Archive

Categories