The Literary Men of Jane Austen
February, the month of love and romance is not over, and Love still lingers in the air like a hint of delightful exotic perfume…
Ripe peaches and heady acacia, sweet honeysuckle, lily-of-the-valley, and the heavenly rose…
Yes, Love with a capital “L” — because this is how the great philosophical abstractions were written in the 18th century and earlier, giving moral, intellectual, and emotional emphasis to Love, Hope, Faith, the Charities, Fortitude, Pride, Ambition, and a myriad other concepts that in our modern era we hardly ever capitalize unless we want to wax nostalgic, or poke somewhat wicked, cynical fun at them (because, you know, we are just way too cool to be earnest).
In Cobweb Bride, my new major semi-historical epic fantasy novel coming in July 2013, I explore Love and all its complex permutations, with abandon.
In the absence of Death,
In the presence of Death,
Only one thing remains,
It is Love.
This is the preamble to the novel, and it gives a hint of what’s to come….
But, besides having an old-fashioned flavor of history, with a rich epic cast of characters (can you say, George R. R. Martin’s Game of Thrones?), what exactly does it have to do with Jane Austen, you say?
Without giving away the several intertwined stories of the many lovers in Cobweb Bride, I can tell you this—it explores Love in all its plurality of ways.
In a world where death has ceased to be, a world suspended—what is there, but Love? It is a thing simultaneously altogether impossible, common-sense practical, satirical, earnest, gothic-romantic, and profound…
Oh and yes, just like Austen, Cobweb Bride has several interesting, romantic, and very intense men! (Wait till you read about Lord Beltain Chidair, the mysterious black knight who roams the forests near Death’s Keep, by order of his undead father, and hunts young maidens who attempt to pass!)
And talking about Love and the men of Austen, we come to the heart (pardon the pun) of the matter. I am going to talk about four distinct categories of Austen men here. So, let’s get to it.
Category One – Romantic Leads of Austen

Mr. Knightley
First, let’s talk about the romantic leads.
Yes, yes, everyone and their mother and grandmother and spinster great aunt, loves Mr. Fitzwilliam Darcy from Pride and Prejudice. In this day and age he is the ultimate romantic lover—a proud, powerful, unreachable, strikingly handsome, imposing man with a gorgeous estate, wealth, and impeccable noble manners, who is brought to his proverbial knees—conquered by his overpowering attraction to the utterly original, one-of-a-kind, independent, smart, eccentric, and charismatic young girl, Elizabeth Bennet.
But what about the other delightful gentlemen that Jane Austen gives us to drool over, to dream about, and to long for in our most private moments?
First, there’s Mr. Henry Tilney from Northanger Abbey. He’s smart, witty, contrary, eccentric, and altogether charming. He is not afraid of laughing and poking fun at all things and even the one person he loves, the innocent and naïve Catherine Morland. But when things come right down to it, he is also terribly brave—brave enough to break with his father and give up his inheritance, for fairness, and for the sake of the woman he loves.
Next, we have Captain Frederick Wentworth from Persuasion. He is a naval officer, a military man of strength, integrity, and a deeply passionate nature. He is also full of courage and masculinity, and he is capable of deep love that he holds on to through the years, despite all odds, and with hope everlasting. When Anne Elliot and he are at last reunited, it is like coming home to the safe harbor of his heart.
Then there’s Mr. Edmund Bertram, from Mansfield Park, the somewhat oblivious, but kind and gentle and very loving young clergyman, and a nobleman’s second son. He is the only one who is genuinely kind to the little poor cousin Fanny Price from the start. His unwavering kindness is eventually translated into love (with the minor hiccup of Mary Crawford in the interim), and in the end they are as happy as two equally kind and harmonious people could be.
Next, we have Mr. Knightley from Emma, another life-long friend, but this one more of a wise, and common sense variety. He sees all the personality faults of Emma Woodhouse and, through his steadfast love-friendship, helps her become a better person, indeed, the best person she could be. His personal nobility of character is powerfully demonstrated when he dances with poor snubbed Harriet Smith—even Mr. Darcy could take a lesson of true gentlemanly behavior from Mr. Knightley!
Then there is Mr. Edward Ferrars in Sense and Sensibility, the gentle very honorable and somewhat timid lover of Elinor Dashwood, possibly the most low-key one that Jane Austen wrote, but maybe that’s okay because the same novel also has the excellent Colonel Brandon…. Edward and Elinor end up quietly happy together, and it is almost a relief to see the happy ending to their sensible love.
And so, up next, the wonderful Colonel Brandon, who is possibly my own personal favorite (together with Mr. Knightley). He loves Marianne Dashwood despite herself, despite the fact that she is infatuated with the handsome and romantic bad boy Wilhougby. When she is at her childish worst, he shows himself at his best, lending a helping hand and shoulder to cry on, and Shakespeare to read.
Category Two – Bad Boys of Austen
And now, we come to the bad boys of Austen:
First, there’s Mr. Wickham from Pride and Prejudice, the devilishly handsome and carefree and charming bad boy we all love to hate. He almost steals Elizabeth Bennet’s heart, but not quite, because truth intervenes, and thus the lying seducer of innocent young girls is revealed to our heroine at least, if not to everyone else (but not before he seduces her silly youngest sister Lydia).
Next, we have Mr. Willoughby, the darkly romantic dream lover—one might almost say he sparkles in dreamy vampire fashion (and when you read my upcoming and hilarious parody Sense and Sanguine Sensibility in 2014, sparkle he will!). Poor Marianne Dashwood is infatuated and falls in gothic/emo love with the impossible perfect lover she thinks he is, a lover she has mostly conjured in her imagination. The real Willoughby is too weak and mediocre to give up a fortune for love. So much for that “dream” lover!
Then there is Mr. Henry Crawford, the brilliant, charming, romantically jaded, smart and exciting bad boy who almost makes it as a real heroic lead, but misses—to quote Agent Maxwell Smart, “missed it by this much!” His initial jaded fascination with Fanny Price almost turns into true love, but unfortunately he turns out to be just shallow enough at the last minute to prove himself unworthy of her steadfast character and love. Oh, Mr. Crawford, if only you had a little more strength of character, just enough to be redeemed!
Next, is Mr. Frank Churchill, the semi-bad boy who flirts mercilessly with Emma Woodhouse, basically using her to disguise his true love for Jane Fairfax. In that sense one might say he is not so much a bad boy as he is someone who demonstrates a careless disregard for the feelings of others and of possibly hurting other people.
Category Three – The Nerds of Austen
Finally we have what I like to call the nerds of Austen. Don’t laugh. Or rather, okay, go ahead, and giggle for all it’s worth!
The most famous one is of course Mr. Collins. He is the most ridiculous, pompous, self-assured and at the same time subservient and brown-nosing character. And he is not only comic relief but a fine bit of commentary on the state of matrimony in Austen’s time. Because, face it, a woman had far more chances of getting a proposal from Mr. Collins (and accepting it like poor Charlotte Lucas) than one from Mr. Darcy.
Then there’s Mr. Elton from Emma. He is also a clergyman, and also self-important and small-minded, thinking himself equal to proposing to Emma Woodhouse, and then mean and vengeful-minded when she refuses him, and disdainful of Harriet Smith. He is not as utterly ridiculous as Mr. Collins, but in a Regency nerd race, he comes a close second.
Next, there’s Mr. Rushworth, the poor cuckold fiancée and later husband of Maria Bertram, a man who has no concept of what is happening around him, and is definitely a pampered, coddled (and over-fed) mama’s boy. His preening attempt at acting in the Mansfield Park play was especially ridiculous, all things considered.
Finally, there’s John Thorpe from Northanger Abbey. He’s a pushy, obnoxious braggart, a bully, and a general knave, so I had to think twice whether to stick him in this category, or the Bad Boys one. However, although he might be a bad boy (or at least he thinks he is one), he is too much of a loser, so in the Regency Nerd camp he goes!
Category Four – Austen Men Created by Others
Finally we come to the fun category of characters that Jane Austen herself never created, but we, the various Austen Authors, did, to populate our continuations, parodies, and sequels.
My own favorite Austenesque romantic lead that I’ve created is Lord Eastwind from Mansfield Park and Mummies. He is handsome, exotic, sexy, and enigmatic. And he is of course the Mummy himself, the Ancient Egyptian Pharaoh whose romantic story is that of tragic ancient love and eternal longing.
When Lord Eastwind takes on human form in Regency England, he becomes an attractive stylish gentleman, and a true rival of both Henry Crawford and Edmund Bertram for the love of Fanny Price, who is his ancient long-lost love.
And now, what about your other favorite male characters that Austen Authors have written? The wonderful Doctor Darcy written by Sharon Lathan comes to mind. And there are plenty of others!
So, let’s hear your favorites!
Vera Nazarian
VERA NAZARIAN is a two-time Nebula Award Nominee, award-winning artist, and member of Science Fiction and Fantasy Writers of America, a writer and reader with a penchant for moral fables and stories of intense wonder, true love, and intricacy.
28 Responses to The Literary Men of Jane Austen
P&P: RC
Be sure to vote!
*Giveaways
Enter our monthly contest using the Rafflecopter form on the
Giveaway Page.
All rules and prizes are listed there! Click the image or link provided.
April 14
Comment to be entered into the Giveaway!

















































































































Facebook
RSS
Twitter
The Writers Block
Oh, Vera…you are talking about one of my favorite subjects EVER! The men of Austen. So much swoon-worthiness here!! Aside from Darcy, of course, I’ll admit to being partial to Mr. Knightley and Henry Tilney. And I can’t leave out Capt. Wentworth when talking about heroes either… In the bad-boys category, I love to hate both Wickham and Willoughby about equally, although, I suspect the former would be impossible to redeem, whereas I hold out a tad more hope for the latter.
Thanks, Marilyn!
You know we can never get enough of this delightful subject!
And I do mean, none of us here! *grin*
My favorite Austen man is Captain Wentworth, but I do adore it so when authors take liberties and make Col. Fitz a lead character. I absolutely crack up over Mary Simonsen’s older Fitzwilliam brother, Anthony.
Enjoyed your post!
Oh, yes, I love Anthony too. A really hilarious character Mary has created. Another author I’m currently reading has a character she’s named Saye (again, Colonel Fitzwilliam’s older brother) who is meant to be a cross between Steff from Pretty in Pink and Rupert Everett in pretty much any part he plays. He’s an unrepentant playboy wild child with a quick wit and a biting sense of humor. When he’s in a scene, you just know there is gonna be a laugh. He reminds me of Anthony, but luckily, he hasn’t shackled himself to a harpy… yet.
Thanks for the fun post Vera. And I think you put John Thorpe in the right place. He’s not hot enough to be a ‘bad boy’. The bad boys of Austen have to have that certain something that makes a woman swoon and want to reform her bad boy. Nothing worth reforming in John Thorpe. He just makes women want to flee by going on about the awesomeness of his gig.
Thanks, Sophia Rose, excellent choices!
Vera, you left out William Elliot of Persuasion. I think he should be in the bad boy category because he’s a real cad and ran off with Mrs Clay as his mistress.
I adore Darcy and love Captain Wentworth. As for other original characters from Austen Authors, the first person that came to mind is Marilyn Brant’s Sam Blaine from According to Jane. One never knows whether he is a Wickham or Darcy until it is revealed in the end. I’m sure there are others that I have read but I don’t remember them now.
Oh, yes, WE’s definitely a bad boy. He meets the ‘hot enough to be potential competition for the hero but then ends up being not honorable’ criteria.
Oh my, yes, I totally did! How could I forget Mr. Elliot!
I think, since I am right now working on Pagan Persuasion: all Olympus Descends on Regency, it is actually getting in the way of my regular Austen character memories of that book, LOL!
Yes, Mr Darcy is my favourite, but Mr Knightley, I think, is a very charming and plessant man as well.
Mr Collins is hillarious, so I can well understand why Mr Bennet enjoys his letters.
I have allways thought that Willoughby is a strange mix of Wickham and Frank Churchill. I think he has the apparence of Frank Churchill and the nature of Wickham. I somehow never liked neither Frank Churchill nor Willoughby. Wickham was after all charming, in the beginning. Though, neither Wickham nor Willoughby turned out to be good natured.
Thank you for this post!
Great comments! I also think Willioughby is an odd mix, though in the long run he is not as unredeeemably bad as Wickham who is hopeless…
I believe Capt. Wentworth and Fitzwilliam Darcy Tie as my favorit Henry Tilney comes in secound.
you have me interested do you have excerpt?
Suze, yes, as to the men!
As for excerpts, there isn’t one for Cobweb Bride just yet (but coming soon, check here), but you can read the excerpt for Mansfield Park and Mummies right here!
Austen men – definitely one of my favorite topics!
As for AuAu-created heroes, I particularly love Mary’s Antony Fitzwilliam, Jack’s Colonel Buford and Sharon’s Dr George Darcy and Randall Artois (Kitty’s hubby).
All excellent choices!!
Vera – I love this piece with the heroes, bad boys and nerds! Very well done! I’d have to say Captain Wentworth is my second favorite after Darcy although it’s a very close second.
As for characters created by other authors, I agree with Monica P! Mary Simonsen’s Antony Fitzwilliam adds comic relief that I think even Jane Austen would have approved of. I also love Colonel Buford (from Jack’s Three Colonels) and Dr. George Darcy (can’t wait for Sharon’s book about him to come out!
I also think Jane herself would have approved our great characters too!
Thanks so much, Susan!
Forget about the Austen men… I want to hear more about Lord Beltain Chidair! That is a FABULOUS name! I am already in love. *swoon
Vera, that cover is astounding. Absolutely amazing. I love it! Whoever your artist is, keep them handy because that is an incredible cover. Yes, I could use even more adjectives, but I think you get the point! LOL!
As for men in Austen, I too have a soft spot for Henry Tilney. A large part of that, I will confess, is because JJ Feilds played him SO well, but he is a fun character. Darcy, and to a degree Wentworth, have that brooding quality that is appealing, no doubt. Yet a fun loving man is definitely enticing.
Great run down list. Really enjoyed this post!
Congrats on the book. It looks and sounds great.
Thanks so much, Sharon!
There will be plenty later about Lord Beltain Chidair and also the Marquis Vlau Fiomarre, both very sexy men in Cobweb Bride. I am so glad you and other people like the cover — as usual it’s one of my own covers (yup, I do all my own).
And I absolutely adore Henry Tilney too!
And JJ Feilds is awesome!
Oh, and thanks for mentioning Dr. Darcy. He is one of MY favorite made up Austen men for sure!
You are very welcome, and he sure is intriguing!!
Terrific post! Colonel Brandon will always be my favorite, but I’m wayyyy too old for him. Mary Simonsen’s Lord Antony Fitzwilliam is my favorite Austen OC.
Great choices, Angie!
And too old? Phooey! We are all eternally young at heart!
Darcy #1 and Wentworth #1.5! Love them both to pieces! I’d like Henry Tilney as a best buddy or brother.
I love Lord Antony Fitzwilliam too, and my all time favorite “new” Austen man is Darcy’s friend and Georgiana’s love interest Lord Dyford (Dye) in the Pamela Aiden trilogy. Am still hoping she’ll write his story someday.
Thanks for the fun comment, rae, and isn’t it just fun making these delightful choices?
What fabulous men!
I am deefinately a Colonel Fitzwilliam fan! I love it when our dear AustenAuthors give him a leading role!
Thank you for the enjoyable post! Like may other readers, I have to vote for Mary Simonsen’s Antony as my favorite character in the 4th category. I hope he gets his own (long) story because it’s so fun listening to his commentary, especially regarding Lady Eleanor. But I’m wondering if there should be another category for the Austen men who didn’t quite make the cut in the first 4 categories — how do you characterize Bingley or Col. Fitzwilliam?
I loved your hero and villain categories. Couldn’t we use a fool category, instead of the nerd one? Nerds are smarter than these guys and do not deserve to be lumped in with these self-centred, thoughtless and/or brain-challenged characters. Nerds are like weeds – they may be unwelcome in some places, but in the right environment, they are appreciated and allowed to blossom.
What are men to rocks and mountains? What are Collinses to Darcies and Knightleys? Let’s get back to the more pleasing men.
I enjoy your work, Vera. Please excuse the quibble.
When I was younger, I preferred Mr. Knightley, but now that I have experienced a bit of life, I find him to be “too perfect,” and, truthfully, that worries me. Can anyone live up to his expectations? LOL! I was never one to want to “change the bad boys,” like so many of my friends would do and then find disappointment. I would likely choose Frederick Wentworth. I love Mr. Darcy from afar, but I would give Wentworth a merry chase in hopes of catching him.