Something’s in the heir
![]()
So, we’re all aware of the parallels between Downton Abbey and Jane Austen’s novels, right?
Family home: in peril. That subject rocks the very foundation of Pride & Prejudice, Sense & Sensibility and Persuasion. Sisters, and no brothers to become the heir apparent. An air of familiarity? A domineering Dowager Countess. Unsuitable suitors.
No surprise, then, that Austen lovers are watching Downton, even though it’s not set in the Regency. Personally, I enjoy picking up on the subtle and not-so-subtle nods to Austen that are intentional from the well-educated screenwriter Julian Fellowes. But even more than that, I have to admit I’m more than a little dazzled with Fellowes’ screenwriting even if the content does at times seem…familiar. But then again, maybe that adds to the show’s universal appeal?
First and foremost with Fellowes’ writing, we notice the pace. For a period drama, the show moves at a fast clip. In early interviews, during Downton’s first season, I read that he was inspired by the pace of American cop shows such as CSI Miami. In fact, during this past Sunday’s Episode 2 of Season 3, I noted an exchange between Thomas and O’Brian that, on the page, couldn’t have been more than four lines of dialogue. It hardly constitutes a scene! Fellowes walks a fine line, I think, when he gives us so little of the scene that we can hardly absorb it before he cuts to the next one.
Too much editing, too many cuts, can make for a choppy and dizzying narrative, and he’s not guilty of the meandering scene, that’s for sure. He’s a writer that knows how to make us salivate for more.

He also peppers his scripts with humor, another endearing move. The one-liners that he graces Maggie Smith’s character with end up as memes all over the Internet, (likes the one above), and for good reason. The writing sparkles. We love it even more that these gems come from an older woman, because, let’s face it, we all want to be the matriarch (or patriarch) spewing one-liners someday. It’s very cool to see an older woman wield such power (Lady Catherine?). Even better: two matriarchs duking it out. What fun it was to watch Maggie Smith and Shirley MacClaine sparring in the drawing room!
In tandem with the humor, Fellowes tends to go for the emotional jugular, and he no doubt tops his pages with that old writer’s trick: what’s the worst thing that could happen to this character? (Lady Edith–Episode 2 Season 3). With every episode we have at least one underdog to root for (FREE BATES!) and then underdogs to the underdogs–Daisy? At this very moment in time, I’m concerned for not only Bates and Daisy, but Lady Edith too. And Lady Edith was rather bitchy in early episodes, yet now we want her to land a better guy than her sisters could even imagine?! Our urge to see the underdogs come out on top keep us coming back, you know.
Admit it, Fellowes has us riveted with the intricate back-stories, love stories and dynamics of the characters he has created. The casting has only added to the sizzle. Yes, Dan Stevens is good looking, but hey, so is Hugh Bonneville, right? Likewise, Michelle Dockery who plays Lady Mary has to be the most gorgeous, expressive young actress I’ve seen in a long time. The way she cocks her head, raises her eyebrows and sighs has me well on my way to a girl crush! We all want the best for her, and yet we all know her happiness will be fleeting. Can’t be gorgeous, rich, and happy for long, can she? Elizabeth McGovern too, rocks her age–she’s 51–and an SNL Downton spoof labeled her a MILF! I don’t like to use that term, but there’s something about having the middle-aged couple on the show looking hot even in their Edwardian clothes and hairstyles.
If you’re a Downton fan, you’re a Julian Fellowes fan, and you may want to see Gosford Park simply because he wrote it. I wanted to see The Young Victoria with Emily Blunt when it came out, but I missed it, and now that I realize he wrote the screenplay, that too will be on the Netflix line-up. Fellowes wrote a couple of novels that might be worth checking out: Snobs and Past Imperfect. As a (conservative) member of the peerage and a manor-house owner himself, Fellowes comes by much of his knowledge of the upper class first hand. What’s great is his ability to skewer the upper class without completely condemning it.
Two ways to gauge any TV show’s success can be measured by how much merchandising and amateur parodies it generates, and Downton has spurred both. You can now buy FREE BATES tote bags and WHAT IS A WEEKEND? t-shirts on the Shop PBS site and who hasn’t seen a spoof or two of Downton floating around on the Internet or SNL?
A better way to measure success: 7.9 million viewers tuned in for the American series premiere of Season 3.
The critics and academics can split hairs about Downton to their pedantic hearts’ content. But we, the people, have spoken.
Thank you, Julian Fellowes, for putting heirs on the air for us Americans.

Karen Doornebos, Author of Definitely Not Mr. Darcy
(If you look closely you can see Parliament in the background of this shot taken from the London Eye.)
Are you watching Downton?
Karen Doornebos
- Web |
- More Posts
29 Responses to Something’s in the heir
P&P: RC
Be sure to vote!
*Giveaways
Enter our monthly contest using the Rafflecopter form on the
Giveaway Page.
All rules and prizes are listed there! Click the image or link provided.
Subscribe
Find It!
Archive
Categories
Authors






















































































































Facebook
RSS
Twitter
I sure am, well watched it already and waiting for season 4
You’re ahead of me & (most) of the US here–some people have season 3 on dvd…
I respectfully differ. I watch Downton for the character actors and its production values. The plot, however, has long since jumped the shark. Jane Austen has Julian Fellowes beaten hands down. Her novels resonate across the ages. With Downton, what I think will linger in memory is the castle and the players, not the cartoonish stories. In this series, Fellowes lacks the sublety and insightfulness of Jane Austen.
Well said, Beatrice. Of course the TV mini series has much less to offer than any novel. Perhaps I didn’t make this clear: for a TV series, I think this is well-written. Plots are stolen from Jane Austen and a plethora of other authors & sources.
I would never say Downton rivals Jane Austen’s writing!
Yikes! Thanks for clarifying! Where’s my coffee???!
I like your comparison to Jane Austen’s novels. But Jane Austen is the one and only with all due respect to Julian Fellowes and his superb Downton Abbey.
Agreed, Aurora! See the comment above!
I have only had a chance to watch the first season. You are so right about the pacing. I have watched many costume dramas that are slow and languid in comparison.
I liked Gosford Park and I didn’t realize the writer was the same.
Thanks for sharing!
Hi Sophia,
Interesting to hear that you enjoyed Gosford Park…I want to check it out!
Much like the above comment I only had the opportunity to watch the first season, but I plan to catch up at some point via online or blockbuster, lol.
Dianna, you can probably get it at the library…although supporting Blockbuster before they go out of business would be good karma
Downton is the only thing I’m watching right now. We are considering cutting our cable but not until I know for sure that I can watch it online. I will definitely the others that you mentioned on my netflix q.
Downton is the only thing I’m watching right now. We are considering cutting our cable but not until I know for sure that I can watch it online. I will definitely put the others that you mentioned in my netflix q.
Hi Evie,
We don’t have cable either–I really don’t watch that much TV–but yes, Netflix is great (or the web)!
I have watched Downton Abbey, and I think it is great. Now I am waiting for season 4 to come. I did in fact watch The young Victoria some time ago, but I did not realise that Fellowes wrote the script before you mentioned it.
Thank you for sharing!
Thank you, Ingrid for your comment! We’re still watching Season 3 here in the states…
Well done, Karen! Yes, I’m watching Downton, although I agree with Beatrice that the plot lines went askew in Season 2. And the whole bit about the money from Lavinia’s father in Season 3 annoyed me. I enjoy the quick pace, and I love some of the minor characters. Sir Anthony’s wedding scene was moving, no matter how unbelievable. Carson’s joyful singing after hearing Mrs. Hughes’s good news was a gem of a finish.
Hi Robin! Yes, there have been some off-the-rails moments, I agree! Thanks for reminding me of Carson at the end, that was sweet, really sweet! I’m a sucker for long-smoldering love!
I never thought to compare Downton Abbey with JA but your analysis is spot on, Karen. I have devoured the third series and can’t wait for the fourth. It’s a great and brilliant series that is truly different from other period drama on tv.
I did watch Gosford Park a few years before Downton Abbey. For me the movie was above average maybe because I didn’t quite catch the accent. I think I need to re-watch it with subtitles on to really appreciate his work.
Just like Ingrid, I didn’t know that JF wrote the screenplay for The Young Victoria. But I love stories about British monarchs so it’s right up my alley. Btw Karen, you did not mention that JF also wrote Titanic mini-series. It’s quite good but Downton Abbey tops it.
Hello Luthien–Thank you for letting us know about the Titanic mini series! I don’t have cable (no BBC America here) so I never saw it. I read mixed reviews. Thanks for your comment!
Waiting to get 3rd season on dvd!! My friend pre ordered it for me for the holidays looking forward to watching..
Gosford Parki watch recently, I enjoyed it but found it a bit sad….
I still haven’t watched Downton Abbey! Will remedy that, one of these days…
Thank you for your post. I have never watched Downton Abbey but I’m quite intrigued now. I don’t have network/cable TV but I do have Netflix and just added it to my queue.
I have seen Gosford Park and loved it though. It was ages ago. Maybe I need to refresh my memory. It’s on Netflix too.
Great post and thanks for pointing out some comparisons to JA. Mind you I think I’d prefer Dowager Grantham over Lady Catherine any day…her one liners are the best! I thoroughly enjoy watching Downton Abbey each season…I’m wishing the best for Lady Edith in the future though I wasn’t very happy with her in Season 2. Mind you, Lady Mary is a bit of an Edwardian diva. Her acting is excellent but she has not been a favourite of mine since the beginning. Julian Fellows has done an excellent job though. I have the dvd Gosford Park and it was excellent. I too missed seeing Young Victoria but plan to remedy that in the near future. From now on, I shall be looking a bit closer for any JA references…
I love watching Downton Abbey!
I didn’t start right away but before the third season started I got seasons 1 & 2 out of the library and watched both seasons in about 3 days.
I’ve only gotten to watch the first 2 episodes so far but I really want to get caught up in one big DA marathon sometime.
From what I’ve read, Julian Fellowes took inspiration from real-life incidents as well as his imagination! I enjoyed the series which we’ve already seen over here. I hope you get Parade’s End which was fantastic and then The Paradise and Mr Selfridge are not far behind.
I hadn’t really compared the two before. I thought that was interesting. I pretty much agreed with carole above. There have been some things I thought totally unnecessary and so some seems just like a soap opera complete with spiteful mean characters like O’Brien and thomas. It’s kind of funny have them pitted against each other. I haven’t watched all of season 3 since it hasn’t all shown here in the U.S. I felt horrible for Edith after last week. I love the Dowager Lady Grantham. Her carefully executed lines with all the wit are just great. I think Lady Mary gets a bad rap she seems to have a warmth emerging. Carson is cute.
Downton Abbey makes for great breakroom conversation at work! Currently watching season 3. There are some great shows that are slow to be released in the US.
I use Downtown Abbey as my guilty pleasure. I spend so much time analyzing plot lines and syntax and pacing that I simply want a few minutes of “me” time. As much as I love Austen, occasionally I need time away from comparing her works to everything else in my life. It is a personal preference, but the only one which keeps me sane.