Janeites… to be or not to be

A few weeks ago (January 27 to be precise) a friend sent me a link to an article her husband was sure I would find interesting.

Janeites: The curious American cult of Jane Austen

A bit of trivia ~ I here apologize to the memory of literary scholar George Saintsbury who coined the term Janeite in an introduction to the 1894 publication of Pride and Prejudice. I thank the Jane Austen Fans of Ireland for setting me straight as I had credited Rudyard Kipling.

Image 1The article was trying to posit an explanation of why Americans like to dress in Regency era clothing, have tea parties and balls and devour sequels not written by Jane Austen.JABall

Laurel Ann Nattress of Austenprose suggested to the author of the article that the elegance of the time is a part of the draw as is looking to the motherland, siting the intense interest in Downton Abbey as an example. Further explaining that Jane wrote only six books and it simply wasn’t enough, people don’t want to give up the characters.

But the overriding conclusion of the article seemed to be that the romance of the stories is what draws people to them even though we know that romance was not Austen’s intent. In fact, Jane created what we see as romance now; successful men who love strong, independent women. She was way ahead of her time. And while I agree with most of the assessment I think the article missed the most important thing that draws people to her and has for two hundred years. At least it is what drew me to her and is the reason my mother gave me Pride and Prejudice when I was fifteen which was my introduction to Jane.

In an era when novels were dark and foreboding she wrote bright, lively tales that often included scandal but scandals that were always resolved without death or destruction. Even Maria Bertram Rushworth in Mansfield Park, who is not allowed the society of her family, is still taken care of in comfort along with her Aunt Norris. As Austen says in reference to this ‘punishment’, “the penalty is less equal than could be wished.

Austenticity2In spite of all the discussions of love and romance, of continuing stories, of wanting to connect with the era and the author via parties and books, I believe Austen’s true appeal comes not from the stories themselves or even the wonderful characters but from her overriding faith in all that is good in humanity.

A strange confluence of small things contributed to this conclusion for me and it is only my opinion as I dare not speak for others. I was watching the Screen Actors Guild awards and something struck me. A large number of commercials for television shows caught my attention. Many, most I’ll say, were for shows I will never watch.

For example: The History Channel has programs entitled Ice Road Truckers; Swamp People and Shark Wranglers; where is the history in that?

Bravo, originally was dedicated to independent films of quality and the performing arts like a live performance of Romeo and Juliet, it now airs Shahs of Sunset and the multiple ‘Real Housewives’ shows.

TLC – The Learning Channel was an information based channel that covered many different subjects including but not limited to medicine, home improvement, cooking, nature and science. Now in the forefront of their programing is ‘Here comes Honey Boo Boo’ and ‘Gypsy Sisters’. What precisely are we learning from those?

tn_D&LThen there is A & E – The Arts and Entertainment Channel that gave us Horatio Hornblower and the 1995 Jennifer Ehle/Colin Firth Pride and Prejudice. Now it airs shows like Duck Dynasty, Shipping Wars and American Hoggers. I see very little entertainment in this type of programing and no art of any kind. Then there are television shows and movies filled with crime, murder and mayhem and shows about fashion, style and living that are mean-spirited and insulting.

All of this supposed entertainment seems to cater to the basest human instincts and emotions in our society. Coupled with the greed of the corporate world as well as the rudeness and lack of manners in the general public, I find that “the more I see of the world the more I am dissatisfied with it.”

Jane Austen had an incredibly strong faith in God and people. In my mind it is not the stories, which were very much ahead of their time, or her wonderful characters that are her genius, but the spirit she infused in all her works: that is her true genius.

While she did make what we would like to believe was everyday life quite pleasant, Jane’s world could be and often was not just unpleasant but dismal. England was at war virtually her entire life; still she opted to portray the good in the world. In Pride and Prejudice Elizabeth tells Darcy to “think only of the past as its remembrance gives you pleasure”. Her books show that this was her own philosophy and not just Elizabeth’s. She even chose to see pleasure not just in the past but in the present, her present. While her brothers were risking their lives aboard war ships, more than one sister-in-law died in child birth and a favorite cousin and sister-in-law was stricken with breast cancer Jane was writing stories to uplift the spirit.

So I have a ‘tea party’ any time someone comes to my house (I always offer tea and baked goods: seldom are they turned down) and whether you pour boiling water over a tea bag in a mug or steep leaves in a pot and serve it in china cups, the tea ‘ceremony’ is civility itself. Sitting with friends enjoying a cup of tea gives me pleasure.

tn_YAJAfinalCoverWhen I wrote Yours Affectionately, Jane Austen I tried to capture the spirit I feel in Jane’s words in the character I wrote and whether I accomplished that is not for me to say but it is her spirit that infuses my life. I wear Regency style dresses because I like them (I’ve been wearing empire waist dresses, which were very popular at the time, since 1967 when I made my first). I carry a fan in the summer and wear a cloak in the winter. I prefer to live a civil and graceful life.  If that makes me a member of the cult of Jane Austen then so be it. People have called me an anachronism but I suppose all of this simply makes me a Janeite. What makes you a Janeite?

Sally Smith O'Rourke

“Where shall I begin? Which of all my important nothings shall I tell you first?” (J.A. June 15, 1808) That I live in the Victorian village of Monrovia, CA, that I work as a surgical scrub nurse. That I have had four novels published, Yours Affectionately, Jane Austen; The Man Who Loved Jane Austen; The Maidenstone Lighthouse and Christmas at Sea Pines Cottage. My current project is Physician, heal thyself which is a story that touches on reincarnation.

10 Responses to Janeites… to be or not to be

  • Lúthien84 says:

    An excellent insight, Sally. I’m not afraid to admit that I am one of those who love Jane Austen’s novels because of the characters and romance infused in her story. For me, being a Janeite means you appreciate her writing and discuss every bit of her novels with fellow like-minded people. I have not got to the stage where I dress up in Regency attire because I don’t have the opportunity to don a Regency gown.

  • Kathy says:

    Thank you for your insightful piece! I really agree with your assessment that Jane Austen’s novels show such optimism. It must make me a “Janeite” that I see now that I do seek out the novels and their variations to read about the rewarding hopefulness of family and relationships. I know that as I’ve gotten older, I’ve also had less patience with reading novels/anything that just keep reminding me of the difficulties in life (or the bizarre — as you pointed out is common on TV these days!) without any sense of hope.

  • Karana says:

    I loved this piece. I love the fact that you wear Regency clothes and have tea parties. I am in love with not only Jane but the time as well. Historial novels/books are where I escape this world for a time when ladies were ladies and gentleman were gentleman. Manners were the upmost importance, as well as civility which I agree is so lacking in society where you now get looked at strangely if you talk appropriately or observe proper manners, or even dress properly for that matter. I have always wanted to throw a tea party and I would wear a dress and bonnet at all times (you should see how many historical patterns I own) but my family and friends try to limit me in that aspect, but all my friends know how much I love Jane and the ideals of the world at that time, even if I don’t look the part. Bravo Sally.

    • Karana:
      I am so pleased you found my post interesting. One of the things I tried to show in Yours Affectionately, Jane Austen because it was something that her books taught me is that it is possible to be true to yourself within the constrains of family and/or society. In P&P Lizzy is political, lively and playful but within the propriety of the day. I too have many historical patterns and have made many of them. I have a Knsale Cloak, a wardrobe of Regency dresses from three different patterns. I was lucky my family not only supported my ‘quirk’ but helped. For our tenth wedding anniversary Mike gave me a silver tea service, he bought me my first bonnet and a fur muff to go with my cloak. My step-daughter gave me a parasol and my sister gave me a custom handmade hat for my tea parties and a china bowl and pitcher. Certainly makes it more fun when friends and family participate. A friend gave me an ink well and stand and a quill. A bit of personal trivia. I wear the empire waist dresses so much that when my grandson (10 at the time) watched ‘The Count of Monte Cristo’ he pointed to one of the actresses and said, “Look she’s wearing a Cubby dress.” I’m Cubby. So get out the patterns and sew away. Have fun, life is too short.

  • Sophia Rose says:

    I love how comments about Janeites illicit an immediate emotional response in me and obviously in others. Many of the negative comments show a lack of understanding for why many of us love Jane Austen. As I read your post, I thought of myself (naturally). I just remember how Jane Austen’s books stood out against all the other great classical writers to me even in school let alone the fact that she is one of the few that I chose to read for personal pleasure without a grade requirement hanging over my head. Her writing style, plots, characters, dialogues, etc were and are just so appealing. There is a lightness to her writing that made a dreary day brighter.

    Thanks for sharing!

  • Beatrice says:

    This is a wonderful article, and I thank you for it. You have written so well about what Jane Austen offers us. Beyond entertainment, she offers the hope we always need – whether we are in despair or filled with joy. She offers an escape from unpleasant reality and disappointing people. She reassures us that things will get better and that there are people to be found whom we can trust and admire. She can be read and re-read, speaking to us in different ways each time, offering just the words and details that most relate to us and our need, mood or circumstance at the time. When I worked in a toxic office, I survived by reading and re-reading P&P nonstop. I knew I would be all right when I was able to move on to S&S, Emma, and Persuasion. Life is much better now (in fact very good), and Jane Austen and her books now augment my joie de vivre. Each time I read the novels I find different things and quotes in them – always so attuned to my life at the time.
    BTW I don’t like the name “Janeite’ – why do we need such a label?
    Maybe I don’t like the label because of the Kipling story – the main character would drop the name “Jane Austen” to get special privileges, in a place and time filled with horror, when those who had read her used her books as a talisman against the death and destruction around them and the thought of the books an escape from it.
    Re TV: More and more I too notice how the TV channels have moved away from their mandate. Several decades ago our cable company announced they would be adding the History Channel “soon”. We were really excited about this; we impatiently waited one long year for its advent. The first night it was available, we cleared the evening for it. And with what show did they mark the auspicious occasion of their first day broadcasting to Canada? They had a little unwatchable gem called “The History of Wrestling in Canada”!

  • I totally agree about A and E tv, there is no longer any art, and I don’t find those reality shows entertaining. They are catering to the lowest of the lowest.
    Why I’m a Janite? I loved 1995′s Pride and Prejudice miniseries, that opened me up to the talent of Miss Austen.

  • Very interesting post, Sally! I would agree that Austen was way ahead of her time, and I love considering all of the reasons why that’s the case. For me, I’ll always feel her genius is in the way she saw human frailies, absurdities, both the best and the worst of people’s behavior…and with such a clear eye. Her observations pinpointed the timelessness of good/bad character in action. I’m still in awe of that ability.

  • Lisa S says:

    Awe, such a sweet post. I like JA’s books for many reasons, but I do think one of them is I too find them uplifting and quite funny. Thanks for sharing your story. :)

  • Stephanie L says:

    Oh where to start. First, I agree with your insights on current television wholeheartedly. I watch very little. Drives me batty all the nonsense that’s on there.
    Second. I am married to a cop and work in HR. I see enough drama and trauma in a day I don’t WANT to go home and read a book about the baser side of our society. I love Jane and the time period because, although there were drama and trauma then, she writes about things that make life feel liveable again. I love the art, the gentility, the formality of it. Back in high school and college, I used to refer to Mr. Darcy and Mr. Knightley when some male would say “hey wanna grab a coke?”. No. I want you to be pleasant and have a conversation and go for a walk with me and just generally be a gentleman. LOL I still have illusions apparently. I wish I possessed even one Regency type garment, but I don’t. I can’t sew to save myself and there’s just no purchasing it here. I just admire from afar. Love that you have a cloak and muff! So elegant! Great piece!

Our Novels

P&P: RC

P&PRC_badgered2Info on P&P:RC page

Be sure to vote!

*Giveaways

Enter our monthly contest using the Rafflecopter form on the
Giveaway Page
.
All rules and prizes are listed there! Click the image or link provided.

Our Imprint

Subscribe

Enter your email address to receive updates of our blog posts.

Delivered by FeedBurner

Contact Us

Authors can be contacted via their email link on the Austen Authors page. For general information or to contact the admins, click the image to the left.

Archive

Categories