Benneton’s Top-Ten: What is it about Mr. Darcy?
I had a post about the dental care (seriously) during Jane Austen time, but as I read it over, I realize I couldn’t do it—inflict on you readers on a Monday dental history horrors, not when I’m going to get a root canal myself this week.
So, as always, when I’m in pain, I arm myself with the best cure there is—Mr. Darcy!
I’m going to recycle one of my favorite blogposts from my blogtour—where I answered a bloghost’s questions: ‘What is it about Mr. Darcy? Why has this iconic literary hero captured the attentions of generations of women in a way no other literary hero has, save Dracula?
(I’ll save my dental care blog for another day for when I can muster a sense of humor about root canal)
Bennton’s Top-Ten of What is it about Mr. Darcy?
Number 10: Teeth. Unlike Dracula, the other iconic literary man who’s captured generations of women’s attention, Mr. Darcy’s canine teeth are harmless. One could safely sleep beside Mr. Darcy from sundown to sunup and have no fear of being struck by immortality and forever frightening little children. Plus, think of the household money you’d save on teeth-whitening products.
Number 9: Duds. Mr. Darcy’s got some cool duds. Okay, I admit the Seinfeld-poofy-white-shirt, and the frilly, snowy neckclothes are a tad overdone, but how could any woman resist a man in gleaming Hessians, exquisitely fitted topcoat, and a pair of buff-colored buckskin breeches?
Number 8: Connections. Mr. Darcy’s got some great connections. He’s the grandson and nephew of an earl. Yet, he’s untitled, which makes it even so much better. You get the benefits of being in high society—without having to call your husband ‘my lord.’
Number 7: Mother-in-law. He’s an orphan. No mother-in-law to worry about. You’ll always get to be the queen bee on Mother’s Day.
Number 6: Friends. He has loyal friends who’ll let him be the alpha dog. Darcy’s best friend Charles Bingley and cousin Colonel Fitzwilliam will always be less confident and poorer than Darcy. Trust me, the cavewomen were right: you always want your man to be the alpha dog.
Number 5: Other women. Junior high girls have it figured out. A boy’s attractiveness increases proportionally on how many other bitchy girls ‘really, really like’ him. Mr. Darcy has other women—bitchy, rich, skinny women like Caroline Bingley—lusting after him. And he didn’t succumb. Didn’t even cast them a pity glance. You’ll always be his dearest, loveliest… even if your figure’s a bit asymmetrical.
Number 4: Children. Mr. Darcy’s a proven, tested father-figure material. He’s been a guardian to his young orphaned sister for years now. And he had a near-miss when his sister almost eloped with a cad, so not only will our Mr. Fitzwilliam Darcy forever be a vigilant father tending to the flock, he’s quite humbled at how hard parenting is.
Number 3: Servants. In particular, Pemberley’s housekeeper, Mrs. Reynolds. Elizabeth Bennet may have fallen in love with him when she saw the grounds of Pemberley, but the cold fact is women fall in love with Pemberley because of his housekeeper. Besides that it speaks very well of a man when his servants adore him, what woman wouldn’t want to be mistress to a house with a built-in, motherly housekeeper? She’ll do the hard work while all you have to do is to approve of menus. And you know Mrs. Reynolds would tell you if there’s a mad wife in the attic!
Number 2: Accent. So cool, so concise, so clipped. That British accent (so much better than a Transvylvania accent) sends shivers down a gal’s spine. That accent tells you he’s got what’s known as British phlegm—that famous British reserve of stubborn endurance. And you want a man who can stubbornly endure anything… especially if your mother bore a resemblance to Mrs. Bennet.
Number 1: Transformation. Unlike Dracula and his descendants, who might sparkle and glitter and transform you, Mr. Darcy’s willing to transform himself. To a better, more improved version. All before marriage.
Bliss!
A man who’s willing to admit he’s been a selfish-being all his life…until you showed him how insufficient were all his pretensions to please a woman worthy of being pleased. (Chapter 16, Pride and Prejudice).
You know this man has learned the important lesson about what’s important in life.
He’s already gone through his navel-contemplation period (before the wedding!). So that middle-age-crisis all sexy, repressed Regency males go through?
Not going to happen.
No third trophy-wife in his future. No impulse-purchase of an arrest-me-red high phaeton at fifty. No growing his hair a la Georgian mullet to hide his bald spot.
How could you resist Mr. Darcy?
I couldn’t. I’m compulsive about Mr. Darcy. I even wrote a novel about it called ‘Compulsively Mr. Darcy!’
Shoot me some novocaine, how about distract me from dental pain with your top three list why a Jane Austen hero is your man! (Darcy, Brandon, Wentworth, Tilney, Knightley…)
Nina Benneton
- Web |
- More Posts
44 Responses to Benneton’s Top-Ten: What is it about Mr. Darcy?
P&P: RC
Be sure to vote!
*Giveaways
Enter our monthly contest using the Rafflecopter form on the
Giveaway Page.
All rules and prizes are listed there! Click the image or link provided.
April 14
Comment to be entered into the Giveaway!























































































































Facebook
RSS
Twitter
The Writers Block
Thanks for the fun post! After the incomparable Darcy, my favorite Austen man is Captain Wentworth. If he didn’t forget you after eight long years, chances are once you’re married, he’ll never forget an anniversary or birthday!
P.S. Advice for root canals – be sure to ask for the nitrous. The rest is a piece of cake.
Susan!
Love that point about after Wentworth’s good memory! How true!
Nitrous, I’ll be sure to ask for that!
Nina, I love your posts! Always fun to see what you come up with next.
Why a Jane Austen hero is my man? Well, like Susan after Darcy it would have to be Capt. Wentworth.
.
I really think he would be THE man for the same reason Susan already wrote – after 8 years of not being in constact still loving!!
Reason two would be that he wouldn´t be too possessive or jealous, I think. You´d still be able to be yourself, and not “only” a Naval Capt. wife – he can be sure of you affections if you haven´t married someone else in the past 8 years
And then there is Henry Tilney, the third Austen hero I have to mention after Darcy and Wentworth.
With Henry it would never get boring.
And all the best with your dentist appointments!!
Katrin,
And it’s ALWAYS a pleasure to see your comment. Thank you. ( Trust me, you don’t want to see my dental blog post. No need to inflict my pain on you guys. )
It’s wonderful to have a man yearning for you for eight years after you spurned him, eh? Especially when you’re still in love with him. I’m getting more enamored by the idea of Wentworth. He may just nudge Brandon out as my #2 JA hero.
A possessive or jealous man is a man to run from, I agree. Although, a tiny bit of jealousy would be good to make sure he appreciates and not take you for granted. It’s the caveman’s mentality.
Henry Tilney! I love him. He’s witty, sexy and you can take him shopping with you. A man who had the general for a father yet managed to be his own man without too much baggage or issue, you know he’s never going to go mid-life crisis on you!
Now, if someone could convince me why Edmund Bertram is hero material….
Lol I so needed this fun post to make me smile today! Thank you. I definitely couldn’t have said it better. Another plus for me would be he’s not overly fond of parties, which I’m not either, at least where I don’t know or like anyone there. I’d much rather keep Mr Darcy at home
Though it would be fun to show him off just a little bit.
I hope your dental visit isn’t awful. You never know, while you’re under the influence of the nitrous you might come up with a crazy awesome plotline for a new story! Lol
Monica,
I’m sure your smile is so much prettier than mine right now.
So true. Darcy’s not a party animal like Bingley, so we know he’ll love to be home to cuddle with us instead of going to parties to see angels.
Nitrous plotting…hmmm…
Love this, Nina! It’s been a rough start to the week, and like Monica said (above), I needed a smile. Thank you!
Awl, so sorry for the rough start. That meant a rough weekend then.
Hopefully your week will get better. Too many Caroline Bingleys in your class?
Nina, this is terrific! Frankly I think Darcy has it up one side, down the other, and around to block over Dracula! I never got the vampire mystique, though. Even Edward from Twilight, who I like better than nasty Dracula, can’t compare with Darcy. I am Team Darcy all the way!!
After Darcy? Well, it is a toss up between Wentworth and Tilney. I like them both, although for different reasons. Getting off Austen, give me the near immortal Aragorn. A half-elf king? Yep, I’ll take him and kick Arwen to the curb!
LOL! You’d go for the half-elf Aragon.
Would that count as fictionalized beastiality still if it’s an elf vs. something with fangs?
I love the top 10! I’m sure we can find even more things to add to the list too.
You will survive your root canal. I’ve had 2 and they really were nothing. I’ve had scarier fillings. Make sure they shoot you up well. Have an ice pack and ibuprofen liqui-gels at the ready. (That type works best for dental issues.) And be sure the doctor sends you home with a prescription for the happy pills. Hydrocodone or such.
Trellowyn,
Feel free to add to more of the list!
Ibuprofen liqui-gels! Thanks for the tip!
Happy pills? Sigh. That’s part of the problem, I have kids who still want their peanut butter not to touch their jelly in their PBJ sandwiches, and happy pills make me sleepy and too loopy (loopier, I should say!).
I love this post. Thank you! You answered this question perfectally.
Thanks, Julie.
Explaining the appeal of Mr. Darcy to non P & P fans is like explaining the appeal of Mr. Spock’s phaser to non-Star Treks fan.
You forgot #1 – he’s got a steady JOB. Carry on.
True. The steady job of being a landed gentleman with an estate. Poofy shirt and all–let me at him.
Lol.. Good post there was YouTube video someone posted last year on the blog “A Darcy befor i die” witch cover Darcy’s appeal.
I have to find that youtube, thanks, Suze.
I’ve always been crazy about Mr. Darcy; now I know why. What I especially like is that you’ve proven that my obsession is founded on perfectly logical reasoning. So no one can criticize, right? As for #2 Austen man, I’m tempted to say Mr. Knightley – although I think that’s based more on the name and Jeremy Northam than any arguement of logic.
I like Jeremy Northam generally, but Jonny Lee Miller was my Mr. Knightley — he really convinced me that Knightley was *romantic.*
Jonny Lee Miller, is he the one who was married to Angelina Jolie?
Yep. He’s a cutie.
Logical reasoning! Thank you! (It was written pain-free, that’s why!).
Good point about Knightley’s name and Jeremy Northam. Got to watch that again.
Really enjoyed this, Nina. I especially like the high school ‘attractiveness’ measure, since Caroline is the indicator!
I love the in-laws comment, too. It makes life much easier when you don’t have in-laws to please; Lady Catherine is bad-enough. Which reminds me — Darcy’s mother was LC’s sister — she might have been a dragon, too.
Thanks for making me laugh.
Ah! You got my drift…. about Lady C and Lady Anne.
Mother’s Day is coming up here this Sunday. We live far from extended families, so I get to be Queen Bee!
I think in lieu of flowers, I’ll ask for a clean garage.
Great list ! My hero is of course Mr Darcy but my number 1 reason isn’t on the list – it’s because he admires an intelligent woman that he can have a real conversation with and doesn’t settle for a shallow air-head society-belle. #2reason is that because he overcame such obstacles to admit his love, he is committed and more likely to hang around as you age and change or new obstacles pop up(not like my husband who unilaterally decided he’d had enough and left for “greener” fields when the going got tough). #3 reason is I know he will take care of me – although I am a strong independent woman, I like to have a strong capable man around that I know i can rely on if I ever needed to. Wow, I sure do have high expectations !!!
Kat,
That is why we intelligent women like Darcy, isn’t it? Because he doesn’t settle for shallow air-heads!
So sorry your guy turned out to be a Wickham. Here’s to a Darcy in your future!
Another point in Darcy’s favor is his commitment to continue educating himself and his love of intelligent debate, but mostly, I appreciate his sly sense of humor, esp when he learns to laugh at himself.
And I appreciate that Wentworth just got on with the business of living and working when he was disappointed in love, unlike Benwick who became morose and full of self-pity.
Brandon and Knightley are okay, but they seem to maintain a fatherly approach to love, and I think an independent woman wouldn’t do at all for them.
All in all, I think the frustration of loving an opinionated man like Darcy would be offset by the extraordinary sources of happiness he would provide.
I find nothing in Ferrars or Tom Bertram or Willoughby or Churchill to cause me to choose one of them. They are so self-centered and weak and whiney – yuk!
Jan,
I so love a man who can laugh at himself! Darcy was opinionated, definitely, but he was WILLING to admit when he’s wrong, and that to me is SEXY. I actually don’t mind opinionated men or people, even if they don’t hold the same opinions as me, to me, they have passion. I rather have that than apathetic peopl.
Good point about Brandon and Knightley being a tad fatherly in their approach. Hmm. You’re right, I don’t think Marianne and Emma were that independent, were they? You’ve given me something to think about.
I love this-you made me laugh out loud!
Good Luck with the root canal-ibuprofen, ice packs and don’t forget to ask for the “happy gas”
June,
And your comment made me laugh out loud, lopsided, but still I laughed.
No happy gas used, but he gave 3 novocaine shots. My biggest beef: he had NO tabloids in his office. I HATE going to male dentists. They’re geeks with no sense of of what a nervous woman needs to read in their waiting room. Excuse me? Golf Illustrated? Argggh!!!
For me, I will always love Wentworth because he is another hero who is willing to admit his mistakes when he confesses his true feelings to Anne in the most loveliest love letter that I have ever read. Unlike gentleman who inherited their fortune like Mr Darcy and Mr Knightley, the good captain is a hardworking person who improve himself and rise to the top from humble beginnings. This shows that gentlemen are not only born into that position but they can be taught.
Nina, love your list btw. Hope you have a pleasant time and laugh off your pain. All the best and take good care.
Thank you, Luthien. I survived and now my smile is almost normal again.
I agree, Wentworth’s letter was one of the most romantic letters I’ve read. You’re right, Wentworth is a self-made man, and that’s very sexy in a way because it makes him more accessible, isn’t it?
Hmmm. I think you’ve given me some ideas for a hero in a story I need to plot soon.
Hilarious! Love the post! You definitely have a point.
Sophia Rose,
Glad you got a laugh!
What a fantastic post, Nina! A marvelous contrast with Dracula for our Mr. Darcy, is spot on!
For myself I would probably go for Mr, Knightley and Colonel Brandon, just as well… Love me some sacrificing men!
Vera,
So glad someone else like that comparison between Dracula and Darcy.
Those fangs really aren’t that attractive to me!
Mr. Knightley, sacrificing? I wanted to bash his head. He was willing to let Emma go to Frank Churchill!
Hi Nina,
As always I loved your post. Your sense of humor is spot on and always makes me laugh!! Frankly I can’t pick a #2 because no one can compare to Mr. Darcy.
I hope all goes well with your dental work. I don’t like the dentist – although if my dentist looked like Mr. Darcy…
Leslie,
So glad you got a few laughs. I tried to think of a way to answer that question seriously, but realized I didn’t have it in me to be an erudite social commentator. I honestly do believe in all those points I listed.
Survived the dental torture. The bill hurt more than the drilling, to be honest. The root canal guy was a little goofy, which actually relaxed me. He gave me a t-shirt that said ‘I survived a root canal.’ For an endodontist, I had to appreciate his sly humor.
I, too, hated going to the dentist until I found this wonderful woman. She’s so wonderful that when she heard I needed to attend some high-falutting social function for research with a story, she called and invited me to a fancy luncheon with the National Society of IMPORTANT people. And then at the luncheon, she bragged about my book. How could I not love her?
Colonel Brandon…Colonel Brandon…Colonel Brandon…
Loyalty…Looks at Marianne like she’s the center of the universe…puts her happiness first above all else…
Oh, and Alan Rickman makes the package complete. Great post!
Angie,
LOL. I’m taking that you don’t think Colonel Brandon is too fatherly?
Alan Rickman! Hmm. You know, he could even play an older Darcy, don’t you think?
Haha thanks for the laugh Nina! I hope you are recovering well from your root canal therapy.
Its Darcy all the way for me! Love your book too!
Vee,
And I LOVE you. Glad to make you laugh. I’m recovering, finally. Today is the first day I wasn’t counting the hours until the next tylenol dose. (can’t take anything stronger, turned out. Makes me more ill). And, I got some writing done today because my head is not fuzzy with pain. Woo hoo!
Nina, this list always, always makes me smile. I think Compulsively Mr. Darcy is the perfect title for your book…and the way your writing makes me feel about him. You always write a wonderful Darcy. I’m still a little in love!